Tensions Erupt on Fox News: Jesse Watters Publicly Calls for Jessica Tarlov’s Removal After Live Clash on The Five

In a moment that has quickly become one of the most talked-about live segments in recent cable news history, Fox News host Jesse Watters openly suggested that co-host Jessica Tarlov should be removed from her position on The Five. The remark, made during a live broadcast, stunned not only viewers but also fellow panelists — triggering an immediate wave of online reaction and renewed debate about the network’s on-air dynamics.

Why Jessica Tarlov loves being liberal voice of Fox News on 'The Five'

What happened wasn’t part of any planned segment. It wasn’t hinted at before the show. And it certainly wasn’t subtle.

A Live Segment Turns Personal

The segment in question began as a routine discussion about the administration’s economic policies — a familiar battleground for the show’s ideologically diverse panel. As often happens on The Five, differing opinions were shared, challenged, and occasionally interrupted.

But this time, the exchange between Jesse Watters and Jessica Tarlov quickly turned from debate to confrontation.

Tarlov, representing the progressive viewpoint, challenged Watters on what she claimed was a misrepresentation of job growth figures. Watters interrupted — not unusual in live TV — but when Tarlov persisted, he fired back sharply, accusing her of being “consistently dishonest with viewers” and undermining the show’s credibility.

Then came the moment that caught everyone off guard.

“Maybe it’s time Fox takes a good hard look at who actually belongs at this table,” Watters said, looking directly at the camera.

It wasn’t phrased hypothetically. It wasn’t framed as a broader question. It was, by all appearances, a public call for her removal — made live, with millions watching.

The Studio Reacts — and So Does the Internet

For a brief moment, the studio went quiet. Co-hosts Jeanine Pirro and Greg Gutfeld shifted in their seats. Dana Perino, known for her professionalism under pressure, attempted to steer the discussion back to the topic, but the mood had already shifted.

Viewers took to social media almost immediately. Within minutes, clips of the exchange were trending, with hashtags like #WattersVsTarlov and #TheFiveMeltdown circulating on Twitter/X, TikTok, and YouTube.

Some viewers praised Watters for “saying what others are afraid to,” while others criticized him for crossing a professional line on live television.

Jesse Watters is Fox News' new 7 p.m. Eastern host

“You don’t publicly try to get a colleague fired in real time. That’s not leadership — it’s ego,” wrote one longtime viewer on Reddit.

The Bigger Picture: Network Culture and Tension

While clashes on The Five are nothing new — in fact, they’re part of what draws viewers in — this moment felt different. According to anonymous production staff speaking with media insiders, the incident wasn’t premeditated, and producers were “completely blindsided.”

Some media analysts believe the moment could signal deeper tensions within the Fox News ecosystem. Unlike other networks, The Five relies heavily on live, unscripted dialogue between strong personalities. That formula has produced top-tier ratings — but it also creates the potential for real-time conflict that goes beyond policy disagreement.

Jessica Tarlov has long served as the show’s lone liberal voice, often taking on the role of balancing — or absorbing — opposing viewpoints from the rest of the conservative-leaning panel. Her presence has been both praised as a necessary counterweight and criticized by viewers who feel her perspective doesn’t represent “the Fox audience.”

Watters, for his part, is one of the most recognizable faces on the network, with his own primetime show and strong support among the Fox News base. His influence — both on air and behind the scenes — continues to grow.

That power dynamic adds weight to what happened during the live broadcast.

Where Does Fox Go From Here?

As of now, neither Fox News nor the show’s producers have issued a formal statement regarding the incident. Both Watters and Tarlov returned to the following day’s show, suggesting that — for the moment — the network is attempting to project business as usual.

But insiders say conversations are taking place.

“Anytime a host suggests removing another host — and does it live — you better believe there are internal meetings happening,” said a former Fox staffer familiar with the show’s inner workings.

What’s unclear is whether Watters’ remark was a moment of heat or a calculated signal to both the network and viewers about the future of the panel’s composition.

Public Perception and the Role of On-Air Conflict

Whether Fox News chooses to publicly address the moment or not, the segment has reignited conversations about civility, professionalism, and the role of on-air conflict in political discourse.

Some argue that such moments are part of what makes live television compelling — unfiltered, raw, and reflective of real disagreement. Others see it as a sign of deteriorating standards in political media, where confrontation replaces substance and ratings drive volatility.

One thing is certain: viewers were paying attention.

A Flashpoint in a Fragile Balance

In many ways, The Five represents a microcosm of American political discourse — passionate, divided, and often on the edge of collapse. What unfolded between Jesse Watters and Jessica Tarlov wasn’t just a personality clash; it was a reminder of how delicate that balance can be, even in a format built on disagreement.

Whether this moment fades into memory or becomes a turning point for the show, the reaction it sparked reveals how closely audiences are watching — and how quickly live TV can become something much bigger than just another segment.