In recent days, Meghan Markle has found herself in the middle of another internet firestorm after a private family video she shared went viral and sparked comparisons with the ever-composed Princess Kate. The Duchess of Sussex, known for breaking royal norms, surprised many by posting a lighthearted twerking video with Prince Harry, celebrating their daughter Princess Lilibet’s fourth birthday. While some applauded her for being relatable and carefree, others accused her of lacking the dignity expected of someone connected to the royal family.

The Video That Broke the Internet

The short video, set to Starrkeisha’s “The Baby Momma Dance,” shows Meghan dancing playfully with Harry inside what appears to be a hospital room around the time of Lilibet’s birth. Intended as a personal and joyful tribute to their daughter, the clip quickly caught the attention of social media users across the globe. Some found it endearing; others saw it as inappropriate, especially when juxtaposed against the traditional image of Princess Kate.

The reel has become Meghan’s second-most-watched video on Instagram, racking up millions of views and sparking a tidal wave of opinions. Royal watchers and fans alike were quick to draw comparisons between Meghan’s fun-loving approach and Kate Middleton’s polished, reserved public image.

A Public Showdown?

According to reports, Meghan became visibly upset after overhearing comments comparing her to Princess Kate at a recent event. Sources suggest she responded forcefully, allegedly stating, “I am NOT her!” The outburst reportedly stunned onlookers, with Kate responding calmly: “Some comparisons don’t need defending.”

That quiet confidence is precisely what Kate’s admirers point to as her strength. Always poised, never caught off-guard, the Princess of Wales has built her reputation on grace and tradition. Meghan, on the other hand, continues to be seen by some as a disruptor—a woman redefining what royalty means in the modern world.

Social Media Divided

The internet, as always, had a lot to say. A 26-second comparison video featuring Meghan’s hospital dance and Kate’s regal appearances at events like Trooping the Colour and the King’s Coronation went viral. Titled simply “Royalty,” the clip sparked fierce debate online.

Supporters of Meghan praised her for being “real,” “normal,” and “joyful.” One top comment read: “Meghan and Harry… happier, real, normal…” Another fan chimed in, “Meghan’s living her life, not as a robot or an AI!”

Critics, however, weren’t as kind. Some users accused Meghan of tarnishing the royal image, suggesting that there should be a clear boundary between celebrity behavior and royal conduct. “This isn’t Hollywood,” one user wrote. “There’s a difference between dancing and representing a centuries-old institution.”

The Celebrity vs. Royalty Debate

At the heart of the controversy is the ongoing debate about what it means to be a royal in the 21st century. Meghan and Harry have often been criticized for blending celebrity culture with royal responsibilities. Critics argue that the two roles aren’t interchangeable—you can be a star, or you can be royal, but you can’t be both.

Kate Middleton’s approach has always been rooted in tradition, duty, and restraint. Her supporters argue that her reserved demeanor helps uphold the monarchy’s stability and reverence. Meghan’s fans counter that expressing joy and vulnerability makes her more relatable and human.

Digging Into Their Pasts

Some have pointed out that Kate herself isn’t without a playful past. Long before she married Prince William, she appeared on the catwalk at a St. Andrews University fashion show. Supporters argue this moment was youthful fun, long before she had royal obligations.

Others argue that the scrutiny Meghan receives seems harsher and more personal. The question becomes: Is the backlash really about behavior, or is it about something deeper?

Feminism, Race, and the Royal Lens

Meghan Markle’s experiences as a biracial woman in the British royal family have already been widely documented and discussed. Critics of the royal institution argue that Meghan has faced unfair levels of criticism and has been held to impossible standards.

Her defenders suggest that if another royal had shared a similar video, the reaction may have been far less severe. In this light, Meghan’s behavior becomes not just a personal choice but a symbolic act of resistance against outdated norms and biases.

Why This Matters

While some may see this as just celebrity drama, the incident highlights broader questions about identity, tradition, and public expectation. It forces us to ask: Should royals be allowed to be more open and expressive? Is it possible to honor the past while embracing the present?

The reaction to Meghan’s video shows that society remains divided on these questions. One side longs for the quiet dignity and formality of figures like Princess Kate. The other side champions transparency, emotion, and breaking away from what they see as performative perfection.

What’s Next for Meghan?

Despite the backlash, Meghan seems unfazed. She has continued to post content to her Instagram account, including a charming day trip to Disneyland with her children and a new promo for her lifestyle brand, “As Ever.”

If history is any indicator, Meghan will continue to do things her way—and her supporters will continue to cheer her on for it. Whether she’s dancing in a hospital room or walking a red carpet, Meghan Markle remains a figure who challenges the status quo and sparks discussion every step of the way.

Final Thoughts

The comparisons between Meghan and Kate are likely to continue, but perhaps it’s time we stopped pitting them against each other. Each woman brings something unique to the table. Meghan challenges traditions and invites authenticity; Kate honors tradition and provides stability.

In the end, maybe the real question isn’t about who’s right or wrong, proper or improper. Maybe it’s about recognizing that there is no one “right” way to be royal—and that the monarchy, like society, might just be big enough for both.