Greg Gutfeld and Tyrus Spotted in Serious Café Meeting — and a Lost Notebook Could Change Everything at Fox News

A routine coffee meeting turned into something much bigger when one forgotten item raised major questions about what’s next behind the scenes

On the surface, it looked like just another meeting between longtime collaborators Greg Gutfeld and Tyrus — two of Fox News’ most recognizable personalities — catching up over coffee. But what unfolded at a quiet café in midtown Manhattan last weekend has sparked buzz and speculation across media circles, especially after a dropped notebook was briefly opened by a curious bystander — and what was inside may shake things up at Fox News.

Eyewitnesses described the two men as unusually serious. Known for their on-screen chemistry and light-hearted exchanges, both Gutfeld and Tyrus appeared deeply engaged, flipping through documents and occasionally exchanging hushed, intense remarks.

“They weren’t joking around like you’d expect,” said one café employee who served them. “They looked like they were planning something big. I mean, the vibe was different — focused, kind of intense.”

The pair sat at a tucked-away table for over an hour, heads together and brows furrowed. According to one customer seated nearby, Gutfeld was seen jotting down notes in a small black notebook throughout the meeting — a notebook that would become the center of attention just minutes later.

As Gutfeld and Tyrus prepared to leave, a small moment of carelessness turned into a potential media scoop. Gutfeld accidentally left the notebook on the table, tucked beneath a folded napkin. He was already halfway to the door when he realized and rushed back to grab it.

But in those brief seconds, a curious customer seated at the next table had already noticed it — and in an impulsive moment, flipped it open.

What they saw, according to a source close to the incident, “wasn’t just notes — it looked like internal drafts, names, and project outlines. Some of it seemed to suggest possible changes in programming, talent rotations, and new show concepts.”

The source, who asked to remain anonymous, said a few recognizable names were listed — including some current Fox hosts whose futures could be in question if the notes reflect actual planning.

“It looked like a playbook,” they said. “And if it’s real, it could mean some big shifts at Fox News.”

While there’s no confirmation on whether the notes represented active Fox News plans, speculation is growing that Gutfeld and Tyrus may be developing something beyond their current roles.

Insiders close to Fox have hinted that Gutfeld has been given “greater creative latitude” in recent months following the ongoing success of his late-night show. There have also been whispers that he and Tyrus — who regularly appears on Gutfeld! and other Fox panels — are working on a side project that blends commentary, storytelling, and satirical news.

Could this meeting have been a strategy session for such a project? Or was it something bigger — a new platform, or even the foundation for reshaping part of the network’s talent strategy?

A spokesperson for Fox News declined to comment.

Greg Gutfeld isn’t new to media disruption. After all, he turned what many expected to be a fringe show into the most-watched late-night program on cable news, frequently outperforming traditional network giants. His mix of sarcasm, cultural critique, and offbeat energy has given Fox News a new kind of edge — and executives are reportedly keen to build on that success.

Tyrus, a former pro wrestler and commentator with a growing fan base, is seen as a valuable asset for expanding that reach.

Which raises the question: Are they just brainstorming, or rewriting the rules again?

Whatever the case, the incident at the café has left media insiders buzzing — not just about what was in the notebook, but what it symbolizes. In an age where network power dynamics shift quickly, even one small, unguarded moment can pull back the curtain on something much bigger.

If Gutfeld and Tyrus are, in fact, planning something new, it’s likely to be bold, unexpected, and — if history is any indicator — wildly popular.

Because when these two sit down for coffee, it’s never just about the coffee.