SHOCKING MELTDOWN ON LIVE TV: Jeanine Pirro EXPLODES at Jessica Tarlov Over “Illegal Immigrant Sympathizer” Comment – DEMANDS FOX News FIRE Her After Defending Alleged MS-13 Member in Unhinged Rant!

In a fiery, no-holds-barred eruption that left The Five audience in stunned silence, Judge Jeanine Pirro unleashed a scathing tirade against liberal co-host Jessica Tarlov, screaming “Get someone else!” in a moment of live TV chaos that now has FOX News viewers and executives reeling.

The explosive on-air showdown came after Tarlov defended Kilmar Abrego Garcia — a Salvadoran national recently deported under disputed circumstances — accusing the Trump administration of violating due process and triggering what she called a “constitutional crisis.”

But for Pirro, that was the last straw.

What followed was nothing short of broadcast history: a conservative firebrand demanding the removal of her own co-host — live, uncensored, and with millions watching.

The Clash That Shook FOX News: A Legal Debate Turns Into Political Warfare

The powder keg ignited over the controversial deportation of Garcia, who had been living and working legally in Maryland before being deported to El Salvador amid unproven accusations of gang ties.

The Trump administration claimed Garcia was a threat to national security due to his alleged MS-13 connections, but critics — including Tarlov — insist those accusations were based on flimsy, even corrupt evidence.

Garcia, who entered the U.S. illegally in 2011 but later obtained a valid work permit, had no criminal record and faced no formal charges of gang activity.

Yet, in March 2025, he was whisked out of the country and dumped into one of El Salvador’s most dangerous prisons — without a trial or chance to defend himself.

Tarlov, visibly shaken, called the deportation a “disgrace” and blasted the administration for using “double hearsay testimony” from a now-indicted detective as justification.

“There is no actual proof this man was ever part of MS-13,” she stated forcefully.

“Sending him to a Salvadoran prison without due process is a human rights violation, not immigration policy.”

Pirro’s Fury: “I Don’t Care About Due Process — I Care About Americans!”

Pirro didn’t just push back — she detonated.

“You care more about illegal immigrants than American citizens!” she shouted, slamming her hand on the desk.

“This man was accused of being part of MS-13.

That’s all I need to know.

Biden’s open border policy is why we’re in this mess!”

Raising her voice to a near-scream, Pirro continued, “The moment we start giving terrorists and gang members the benefit of the doubt, this country is DONE.

If Jessica wants to defend them, then maybe she should be the one deported!”

The crescendo came with her now-infamous demand: “FOX needs to GET SOMEONE ELSE! Enough of this liberal lunacy!”

A Split That Could Tear The Five Apart

The backlash was immediate and fierce.

Viewers flooded social media, some cheering Pirro’s passion, others accusing her of authoritarian overreach and calling for her suspension.

The tension between the two co-hosts, always simmering, has now exploded into what some insiders are calling an “irreparable fracture.”

Behind the scenes, FOX executives are said to be scrambling to do damage control.

According to internal sources, producers were “caught completely off guard” by the segment’s meltdown and are reviewing whether disciplinary action is warranted for either host.

Meanwhile, Jessica Tarlov has stood her ground, doubling down on her defense of Garcia and warning that ignoring due process in the name of security is a dangerous path.

“This is how constitutional democracies crumble — one ignored right at a time,” she said in a follow-up statement.

“This isn’t about politics.

It’s about justice.”

Constitutional Crisis or Conservative Overreaction?

What makes this clash more than just cable news drama is the chilling legal precedent it could set.

Tarlov, along with Democratic Senator Chris Van Hollen, argues that Garcia’s deportation was not only a miscarriage of justice but a direct violation of international human rights norms.

Garcia was deported under the Alien Enemies Act, an obscure piece of legislation originally intended for wartime threats — not for immigrants with valid work permits.

Critics argue this misuse of executive power erodes fundamental civil liberties and invites further abuse.

“This isn’t just about Garcia,” said Van Hollen.

“This is about every single person on U.S. soil who could now be disappeared in the dead of night based on anonymous accusations.

That is not who we are.”

America’s Immigration Divide, On Full Display

At its core, this is a battle over what kind of country America wants to be.

For Jeanine Pirro and her supporters, it’s about hardline national security: protect citizens first, ask questions later.

For Jessica Tarlov and progressives, it’s about ensuring justice and due process — even for those with questionable immigration status.

The Kilmar Garcia case has become a litmus test for both sides.

Are we willing to sacrifice due process in the name of public safety? Or are we willing to risk public safety to uphold the rule of law?

This ideological war is no longer theoretical.

It’s playing out in prime time — and threatening to implode one of FOX News’ most popular shows in the process.

What’s Next? Will Tarlov Be Pushed Out or Will Pirro Face Backlash?

As the fallout continues, speculation is swirling about whether Tarlov will be quietly removed from The Five or whether FOX will take action against Pirro for crossing a line.

Viewers are already choosing sides, with hashtags like #StandWithJessica and #FireTarlov trending simultaneously.

What’s certain is that the shouting match between these two political heavyweights has exposed a gaping wound in America’s immigration debate — one that won’t be healed with sound bites or slogans.

Whether you side with Pirro’s scorched-earth tactics or Tarlov’s legal arguments, one thing is clear: the fight for America’s soul is no longer happening in Congress — it’s happening on your television, live and uncensored.

And it’s only just begun.