Social Media Fans Have Spoken – John Foster and Jamal Roberts Are the Real American Idol Winners in 2025

As American Idol 2025 inches toward its grand finale, two names are dominating social media conversations across the country: John Foster and Jamal Roberts.

While the competition remains fierce, fans have already crowned their winners in spirit, praising the authenticity, artistry, and heart that these two standout performers bring to the stage each week.

Whether it’s Foster’s traditional country charm or Roberts’ soulful gospel power, viewers have made it clear—these are the real stars of Season 23.

Eighteen-year-old John Foster from Addis, Louisiana, has mesmerized audiences with a voice that feels decades older than his age. A true country traditionalist, his musical style echoes legends like Randy Travis and George Strait, bringing nostalgia and sincerity back to the genre.

Foster’s emotional performance of “I Told You So” drew tears from guest mentor Carrie Underwood and immediately went viral, catapulting him into national recognition. Fans quickly rallied around the young singer, calling him “the future of country music” and “a voice we haven’t heard in years.”

Meanwhile, Jamal Roberts, a 27-year-old gym teacher and devoted father from Meridian, Mississippi, has struck a different chord—one rooted in perseverance and faith.

Balancing parenthood with his lifelong dream, Roberts has become a symbol of second chances and determination. His rendition of Fantasia’s “I Believe” left judges and fans alike in awe, resonating with the emotional weight of his journey.

The birth of his third child shortly before entering the Top 7 only deepened the public’s admiration for his resilience and heart.

Both Foster and Roberts have built massive online followings, with Instagram, X (formerly Twitter), and TikTok filled with fan tributes, reaction videos, and voting campaigns.

Foster’s Louisiana fanbase is particularly vocal, with some users proudly claiming to have voted “30 times a night” to keep him in the running. Roberts’ supporters have coined hashtags like #JusticeForJamal and #RobertsDeservesTheCrown, celebrating his every performance with messages of love and encouragement.

While American Idol remains a competition decided by votes and judges, the groundswell of public sentiment surrounding these two artists cannot be ignored.

Comment sections and fan forums overflow with praise, often declaring, “No matter who wins, John and Jamal are our idols.” The narrative is clear: for many Americans, this season’s emotional center has been shaped by these two men.

As the finale looms, the spotlight grows brighter—and so does the anticipation. Will the official results align with public opinion? Whether or not they take the title, both John Foster and Jamal Roberts have already won the hearts of millions.

Their journey is no longer just about a trophy, but about the legacy they’re building—one song, one story, and one fan at a time.